|
Post by ProkAdama on Oct 15, 2012 15:03:38 GMT
15 marksmens. 10 Light machine gunner. 100 standard soldiers. 3 Heavy machine gunner 1 light tank. 1 medium tenk. 5 jeeps.
vs
L82A1 Riflemen - 60 L82A1 Grenadiers - 18 L83A1 Light Support Weapons - 9 L19A1 Marksman Rifles - 9 MILAN Anti-Tank missile systems - 9 Multi-purpose AT/AA Missiles - 18
Mastiff I Protected Patrol Vehicles - 9 Land Rovers (Long Wheel base) - 2
22nd Armour Support Squadron, Royal Scots Dragoon Guards:
L82A2 Riflemen - 22 Land Rovers - 3 Challenger 2 MBT's - 19
You saying he should win this instance? You had much more armour but he was superior than you in infantry numbers - therefore I will change that to ALL brit infantry EXCEPT for (L19A1 Marksman Rifles - 9). Two MBTs because I said two MBTs.
He wouldn't have been able to counterattack since all of his forces were dead by that time. He had no proper AT defences BUT he had an MBT and a light tank, not to mention an infantry unit might have destroyed a tank via RP-like methods (throwing a grenade inside, sniper, whatever, something happened)
|
|
sgtsammac
Ruler of the United Kingdom
Death to the kingdoms enemies.
Posts: 2,988
|
Post by sgtsammac on Oct 15, 2012 15:07:25 GMT
When did I say he should win.... You're coming off as an asshole dude.
I asked a simple question about how I lost so much because I was not sure and simply wanted a bit of clarity. Considering his lack of detail in posts and the fact that I launched a full on suprise attack.
Also he didn't post any offensive he only posted that his troops went into hiding.
|
|
|
Post by ProkAdama on Oct 15, 2012 15:17:11 GMT
You are questioning my reasoning - I see that you are unsatisfied with the amount of troops you lost... I will give you a full analysis.
Well first of all, you shouldn't curse without censoring - it's your own standard.
Second, it was indeed a surprise attack, but it was done before the enemy even showed up or gave strategy (too early).
Third, he had a larger amount of infantry, so a lot of these soldiers would counterfire against your troops. You would have lost more if it wasn't a surprise attack.
Fourth, he didn't have any AT support, but he did have two tanks - if they were lucky, they defeated two of your MBTs. Consider them lucky in this case.
Fifth, you would have lost more if you didn't do the bombing that finished him off.
Sixth, detailing of posts doesn't play that much of a role - in fact, I think his posts weren't that underdetailed, they were on par gameplay-wise even if it had terrible grammar. Either way, it's for the BM to decide, not the player who obviously wants to win by losing the least.
|
|
sgtsammac
Ruler of the United Kingdom
Death to the kingdoms enemies.
Posts: 2,988
|
Post by sgtsammac on Oct 15, 2012 15:21:21 GMT
I'm not unhappy with my losses. I ASKED FOR FREAKING CLARITY!
Jesus h. christ!
Also, I am so sorry I didn't realise that 1 30mm gun and a Challenger 2 can destroy 2 out of 19 Challenger 2's in force.
|
|
|
Post by rainbowwig on Oct 15, 2012 16:46:30 GMT
Prok, how did you even mod? Srbin didn't post any real tactics. You cannot mod without both tactics.
|
|
|
Post by srbin4 on Oct 15, 2012 17:14:17 GMT
I dont know whether i need to be sad or happy but i am so happy destroyed 23250$
|
|
|
Post by ProkAdama on Oct 15, 2012 17:25:28 GMT
@sammac
As many of you have said before - this is a "game" that "isn't supposed to resemble reality so much" - therefore it is not EXTREMELY strict, AKA one challenger could have taken out 2, by luck.
Also, you are quite obvious that you are unhappy with your losses, as you would not have posted otherwise.
@adam
Fist of all, "Either way, it's for the BM to decide, not the player who obviously wants to win by losing the least."
Second off, I'm not going to ask him for tactics AGAIN, so I used what I had.
Third off, he DID post tactics. Even if they are not tactics on your standard. After Sam did the double cross thing -
"Serbian soldiers pull back to shelters which are made in 1970 that are in other side of city.They got the order to make tactic scorched earth.They find old tunnels at shelter.Small squad formed of 5 standard soldiers are sent in scouting mission."
Of course, they failed to ever get to these tunnels and died in a phosphorous hell. But I assume that soldiers will shoot back when they get shot at.
(I am not trying to aggravate anyone here, but rather trying to explain my position.)
|
|
|
Post by rainbowwig on Oct 15, 2012 18:15:40 GMT
I believe that Srbin should have had the chance to prove that he defended himself. I also think it's a bit weird that every troop died at once. It's not I who complain about Sam's losses. I complain about how it was modded, since it doesn't seem proper.
|
|
|
Post by srbin4 on Oct 15, 2012 19:01:21 GMT
Of course, they failed to ever get to these tunnels and died in a phosphorous hell. But I assume that soldiers will shoot back when they get shot at.
This is reason my soldiers all died at once. And why you choose Serbia? Bosnia has more petroleum than Serbia and Montenegro has sea Serbia don't. I just don't see reason why Serbia?
|
|
|
Post by rainbowwig on Oct 15, 2012 19:25:33 GMT
I don't care for petroleum. I am the king of Saudi Arabia, not United States of America. I chose Serbia purely out of the fact that Serbia is strong.
With this defeat, the king advances into the presidential palace of Serbia and faces the president of Serbia. As the president of Serbia is weak and unarmed, the king of Valhall decides to not use his firearm. Instead he walks up to the president of Serbia and pushes him up the wall, stabbing him in the gut. The blood flows out and makes his hand red. The king moves away from the president of Serbia and lets him bleed on the floor before picking him up by the collar and slams his head onto the desk. The king takes the letter-opener and stabs it in the president's shoulder. As the president screams in pain, the king of Valhall throws him out the window, letting him fall to his death.
|
|
|
Post by ProkAdama on Oct 15, 2012 20:24:13 GMT
Wow. That's disgusting. Hard to believe a clown-looking guy murdered you so brutally XD
"Of course, they failed to ever get to these tunnels and died in a phosphorous hell. But I assume that soldiers will shoot back when they get shot at.
This is reason my soldiers all died at once. And why you choose Serbia? Bosnia has more petroleum than Serbia and Montenegro has sea Serbia don't. I just don't see reason why Serbia? "
I agree with this. I had enough material to make a final post - there was no chance of them surviving a carpet bombing of fire.
|
|
|
Post by srbin4 on Oct 16, 2012 19:13:50 GMT
But maybe jeeps survived they are quite fast?
|
|
sgtsammac
Ruler of the United Kingdom
Death to the kingdoms enemies.
Posts: 2,988
|
Post by sgtsammac on Oct 16, 2012 19:16:16 GMT
A) You're a bit late. B) Jeeps are not going to survive the amount of AT and tanks I had/have, C) The bomber would have cleared them up. D) You didn't post proper tactics and thus your troops died anyway. You have lost Serbia. Deal with it.
|
|